Kniefall Von Warschau
Event
The event took place on December 7, 1970, in Warsaw, Poland, during a visit to a monument to the German occupation-era Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. After laying a wreath, Brandt unexpectedly, and spontaneously, knelt. He remained silently in that position for a short time (about 30 seconds), surrounded by a large group of dignitaries and press photographers. Brandt had actively resisted the early Nazi regime, and had spent most of the time of Hitler's reign in exile. The occasion of Brandt's visit to Poland at the time was the signing of the Treaty of Warsaw between West Germany and Poland, guaranteeing German acceptance of the new borders of Poland. The treaty was one of the Brandt-initiated policy steps (the 'Ostpolitik') to ease tensions between West and East during the Cold War.
Reactions
This section needs additional citations for verification. (December 2015) |
In Germany
On the same day, Brandt signed the Treaty of Warsaw, which acknowledged the Oder–Neisse line as the final German border with Poland. Both actions attracted controversy within Germany, as did Ostpolitik in general, which was supported by only a narrow majority of the people and had opposition within Brandt's own Social Democratic Party. Its voters had included a significant proportion of expellees from the formerly-German territories in Poland, most of whom left to support the conservative parties.
According to a Der Spiegel survey of the time, 48% of all West Germans thought the Kniefall was excessive, 41% said it was appropriate and 11% had no opinion. Brandt's victory in the next elections, in late 1972, was also due to the growing view among voters that Brandt's Ostpolitik, symbolized by the Kniefall, and his reformist domestic policies were helping to boost Germany's international reputation and so should be supported. His party won its best federal election result ever.
Internationally
While at the time, positive reactions may have been limited, his show of humility was a small but vital step in bridging the gaps World War II had left between Germany and Eastern Europe. In historical terms, Brandt gained much renown for this act. He was named Time Person of the Year in 1970, with the magazine highlighting the Kniefall as one of the main reasons for his recognition, and it is thought to be one of the reasons he received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1971.
A monument to Willy Brandt was unveiled on 6 December 2000, in Willy Brandt Square in Warsaw (near the Warsaw Ghetto Heroes Monument) on the eve of the 30th anniversary of his famous gesture.
Brandt's memories
Brandt was repeatedly interviewed about the genuflection and about his motives. He later noted that:
- (German original) "Am Abgrund der deutschen Geschichte und unter der Last der Millionen Ermordeten tat ich, was Menschen tun, wenn die Sprache versagt."
- (English translation) At the abyss of German history and under the weight of millions of murdered people, I did what people do when language fails.
Egon Bahr, an eyewitness and Brandt's friend and political ally of many years, recalled in a 2010 interview: "The only thing he said was that at that moment facing the ribbon, he thought: Just laying the wreath is not enough."
Later Reception
Reviewing the Kniefall one tends to agree that it played an Important part in easing the tension between the eastern and western block. The Treaty of Warsaw 1970 was signed on the very same day and it included the inviolability of the Oder-Neisse-line. Józef Cyrankiewicz(1911-1989) the polish prime minister and survivor of the Auschwitz Concentration Camp signed. To expand on Brandt's memories, here are some later receptions:
There is a lot of speculation whether Brandt did this spontaneously. Willy Brandt wrote about that in his memoars Erinnerungen (reminiscences):
"Again and again I have been asked what the deal was with the gesture. Was it planned? No, it wasn't. My closest colleagues were as surprised as those reporters and photographers standing close to me, as well as those keeping their distance, as they did not expect anything new. [...] I did not plan anything, but left Wilanów Palace with the feeling that I have to represent the special remembrance of the ghetto monument. At the abyss of german history and the weight of millions that have been murdered, I did, what humans do when speech fails them."
Egon Bahr said in his reminiscence Zu meiner Zeit (Back in my time) 1966:
"Right as the motorcade moved towards the ghetto monument, Berthold Beitz and me compared our impressions. We calmly got out of the car and were in no hurry to get closer to the journalists and photographers - then everything went quiet. It is rare for this hard-boiled crowd to be silenced. While coming closer, someone whispered >>He's kneeling.<< I've just seen the picture, when it already went around the world. I did shy away of asking my friend during the las whiskey at the evening. That someone, who is free from any historic guilt will aknowledge the historic guilt of his people, came to my mind, but grand statements between us where uncommon. >> I've had the feeling that bowing my head won't be enough<<."
Walter Scheel wrote a letter to the news magazine Solinger Tageblatt in 2010 stating:
"In the moment, as we got out of the car and went infront of the monument the overall mood was overhelming. Suddenly Willy Brandt went down on his knees, and everyone attending would have wanted to do the same. Everyone recognized this unplanned and spontaneous gesture as unique and impressive. [...] It was one of Willy Brandts abilitiy, that I appreciated so much, to emotionally speak to the people and to set an for everyone recognizable example. I have never whitnessed a comparable politician."
On December 7, 2010 the federal president Christian Wulff and the polish president Bronislaw Komorowski, on its fortieth anniversary, hold speeches about the meaning of this Kniefall for the polish-german reconciliation. They were invited by Friedrich-Ebert Foundation in Warsaw and layed wreaths at the monument for the Warsaw Uprisings and the monument for theores of the Warsaw Ghetto.
The writer Navid Kermani said in a celebration for 65 Jahre Grundgesetz (lit. 65 Years of german constitution) in the German Bundestag on May 23 2014:
"When and how did Germany, that was already regarded with suspicion due to it's militarism in the 19th century, and seemed to be completely dishonored with the murder of 6 million jews, when and how did Germany regain it's dignity? If I had to name a single day, a single happening, one gesture, that would show the word of 'Dignity' in german post war history, then it would be the 'Kniefall von Warschau'."
The historian Michael Wolffsohn claimed on the fiftieth anniversary in 2020 on the german TV Channel ARD-alpha, that it has been "a wonderfull symbol but for that time completely wrong symbol for the adressee". There was no real reception in the polish population. Wolffsohn believes, that the reason for that Willy Brandt, as other politicians, made a mistake. Apparently Brandt had mistook the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising with the Warsaw Uprising.
Similar act
During a visit to the former Seodaemun Prison in Seoul in August 2015, former Japanese prime minister Yukio Hatoyama knelt in front of a memorial stone as an expression of apology for Japanese war crimes in World War II.
See also
References
- ^ "The Nobel Peace Prize 1971". NobelPrize.org. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
- ^ "Willy Brandt-'Warsaw Genuflection' (Eng&Ger Subs)". 100 Years - The Countdown - 1970. YouTube / Zolcer TV / ZDF History. 23 December 2013. Archived from the original on 2021-12-21. Retrieved 20 February 2014.
- ^ "KNIEFALL ANGEMESSEN ODER ÜBERTRIEBEN?". Der Spiegel (in German). 1970-12-13. ISSN 2195-1349. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
- ^ "Man Of The Year: On the Road to a New Reality". Time. January 4, 1971. Retrieved 14 December 2022.
- ^ Kniefall in Warschau Archived 2007-09-27 at the Wayback Machine (German) (from the willy-brandt.org website)
- ^ Unofficial translation of the above lines in a German interview of Brandt
- ^ "Interview: "Plötzlich flüsterte einer: Der kniet!"". Der Tagesspiegel Online (in German). ISSN 1865-2263. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
- ^ (Willy Brandt: Erinnerungen. Propyläen-Verlag, Frankfurt am Main 1989, S. 214.)
- ^ (Egon Bahr: Zu meiner Zeit. Blessing-Verlag, München 1996, S. 341.)
- ^ Brandts Kniefall: Solinger Scheel erinnert sich. In: Solinger Tageblatt, 8. Dezember 2010].
- ^ Rede von Dr. Navid Kermani zur Feierstunde „65 Jahre Grundgesetz“. In: Deutscher Bundestag. (bundestag.de [abgerufen am 20. November 2016]).
- ^ Hongo, Jun (13 August 2015). "Former Prime Minister Hatoyama Kneels at Wartime Prison in Seoul". The Wall Street Journal. Archived from the original on 17 August 2015. Retrieved 21 November 2017.
External links
- Photo of the Kniefall (photographer: Engelbert Reineke)
- Cover of German news magazine "Der Spiegel" with image of Brandt in front of the monument (photographer: Sven Simon)
- Photo of the Kniefall including wreath, Photographer Hanns Hubmann
- 1970: This photo of a German chancellor went down in history. Why? | History Stories (short documentary on YouTube by Deutsche Welle)