The series was nominated for 24 Primetime Emmy Awards, with a leading eight wins at the 75th Primetime Creative Arts Emmy Awards. Ramsey, who identifies as non-binary, considered withdrawing due to the lack of non-gendered categories following Liv Hewson's withdrawal for Yellowjackets, but decided to contend for Lead Actress after discussions with Mazin, not wanting limited language to prevent celebrating non-binary performers; Ramsey's is the second non-binary acting nomination and the first for a leading role at time of nomination. Woodard is the second-youngest Emmy nominee, the youngest ever for Guest Actor in a Drama Series, and the first nominated black deaf and second deaf actor, while Pascal is the second Latino nominated for Lead Actor in a Drama Series and the first since 1999.
Michael J. Benavente, Chris Battaglia, Chris Terhune, Mitchell Lestner, Matt Yocum, Randy Wilson, Davi Aquino, Justin Hale, Justin Charbonneau, Stefan Fraticelli, William Kellerman (for"When You're Lost in the Darkness")
Michael J. Benavente, Joe Schiff, Christopher Battaglia, Chris Terhune, Mitchell Lestner, Jacob Flack, Matt Yocum, Maarten Hofmeijer, Randy Wilson, Justin Hele, Davi Aquino, Stefan Fraticelli, Jason Charbonneau, and William Kellerman (for"When You're Lost in the Darkness")