The Sorcerer (cave Art)
Breuil's drawing
Henri Breuil asserted that the cave painting represented a shaman or magician — an interpretation which gives the image its name — and described the image he drew in these terms. Margaret Murray having seen the published drawing called Breuil's image 'the first depiction of a deity on Earth', an idea which Breuil and others later adopted.
His views held sway in the field for much of the 20th century, but they have since been largely superseded.
Breuil's image has been commonly interpreted as a shaman performing a ritual to ensure good hunting.
Critique
Certain modern scholars question the validity of Breuil's sketch, claiming that modern photographs do not show the famous antlers. Ronald Hutton theorized that Breuil was fitting the evidence to support his hunting-magic theory of cave-art, citing that "the figure drawn by Breuil is not the same as the one actually painted on the cave wall." Hutton's theory led him to conclude that reliance on Breuil's initial sketch resulted in many later scholars erroneously claiming that "The Sorcerer" was evidence that the concept of a Horned God dated back to Paleolithic times.
Likewise, Peter Ucko concluded that inaccuracies in the drawing were caused by Breuil's working in dim gas-light, in awkward circumstances, and that he had mistaken cracks in the rock surface for man-made marks.
Also, "the Sorcerer" is composed of both charcoal drawings and etching within the stone itself; details, such as etching, are often difficult to view from photographs due to their size and the quality of the light source. Particularly celebrated prehistorian Jean Clottes asserts that Breuil's sketch is accurate, saying "I have seen it myself perhaps 20 times over the years", yet failed at providing evidence.
Continuing influence
The general assessment has placed the figure as central to an understanding of cave art: as S. G. F. Brandon expressed it in 1959, "it seems to be generally agreed that this picture of the 'Dancing Sorcerer' was a cult object of great significance to the community which used the cave."
Popular culture
Breuil's interpretation of the drawing as a shaman strongly influenced writer Pat Mills in the creation of the Lord Weird Slough Feg, an early antagonist in the Slaine comics.
The 1996 novel The Story of B by Daniel Quinn includes an interpretation of the painting as an expression of late Paleolithic animism, a symbol for the human sense of identity with other animal life.
In Sunset of the Sabertooth, a 1996 installment of the Magic Tree House children's book series, the Sorcerer is depicted as a shaman-like traveler who rescues the protagonists, Jack and Annie, and helps take them home.
See also
References
- ^ "Trois Frères - cave, Ariège, France".
- ^ Henri Breuil, Quatre cent siècles d'art paiétal (Montignac, 1954, p. 166 (Mary E. Boyle, tr., as Four Hundred Centuries of Cave Art, London: Zwemmer, 1952); Breuil, Les Cavernes du Volp, 1958.
- ^ Brandon, S. G. F. (1959). "The Ritual Perpetuation of the Past". Numen. 6 (2): 112–129 (112). doi:10.1163/156852759X00110.
it seems to be generally agreed that this picture of the 'Dancing Sorcerer' was a cult object of great significance to the community which used the cave.
- ^ Hutton, Ronald (2003). Witches, Druids, and King Arthur. London: Hambledon and London. pp. 33–35. ISBN 1-85285-397-2.
- ^ Jean Clottes and David Lewis-Williams The Shamans of Prehistory: Trance and Magic in the Painted Caves
- ^ Ucko, P. (1992). Subjectivity and the recording of Palaeolithic Cave Art, in T. Shay & J. Clottes (eds), The Limitations of Archaeological Knowledge, 141–180. Liege: University of Liege Press
- ^ "Cave Art Cobblers? - Beachcombing's Bizarre History Blog". 6 July 2011.
- ^ "The Origins" (two-page text article), 2000 AD #352, 1984